Hue Citadel - review by Rusty Compass
Hue | see and do guide

Independent reviews and recommendations by Rusty Compass. No advertorial, no paid placements and no sponsored content.

Hue Citadel

| 03 Jan 2016
  • 11 of 23

Map

Map
Hue Citadel
23 Thang 8, Hue
7.30 - 5.00PM
150,000VND

Map
Our rating
03 Jan 2016

Hue’s Imperial Citadel is the centrepiece attraction of the former royal capital. It was the home of Vietnam’s last royal dynasty, the Nguyen Dynasty (1802 - 1945). Despite being severely damaged in twentieth century wars, the Citadel remains Hue’s most popular and most important historic site.

Note: The information provided in this review was correct at time of publishing but may change. For final clarification please check with the relevant service

Hue’s Imperial Citadel isn’t terribly old. But war, neglect and time, have all taken their toll over its two century existence. Most of the complex is in ruin.

Set back from the Perfume River, the Imperial Citadel dates from the beginning of the nineteenth century and the founding of Vietnam’s last royal dynasty. The Nguyen kings, whose rule was mostly blighted by French colonisation, nominally ruled from within the citadel walls until the last king, Bao Dai, abdicated here in favour of Ho Chi Minh’s revolutionary forces in 1945.

Construction commenced in 1804 following founding Emperor Gia Long’s successful unification of Vietnam. The structure is modelled on Beijing’s Forbidden City. French experts were recruited to lend their engineering expertise. The walls are built in accordance with the principles of 17th century French military engineer, Vauban.

The early 19th century was a time when creeping French influence throughout Vietnam seemed to be relatively benign. By the last decades of the nineteenth century however, the French had colonised the whole of Vietnam and located their colonial base in Hanoi. The Nguyen Emperors were reduced to figureheads - some willingly, others reluctantly.

The abdication of Emperor Bao Dai in September 1945, marked the end of the troubled Nguyen Dynasty and ushered in a period of turmoil in Vietnam that took a tragic toll on the country and the citadel alike.

A fire swept through in 1947 destroying many of the imperial buildings.

In 1968, in the Tet Offensive’s Battle of Hue, one of the Vietnam War’s most deadly confrontations, took place in and around the citadel. Only a handful of structures survived the US aerial bombings and ground battles as North Vietnamese forces fought to hold on to the symbolically important terrain.

The National Liberation Front (NLF) flag flew from the citadel’s massive flag tower for three weeks before South Vietnamese and US forces succeeded in reclaiming the shattered imperial structure. The damage wrought by shelling and automatic weapons fire is still visible around the complex walls.

Since its listing as a World Heritage site in 1992, many ruined buildings have been restored. The levelling of the vast Forbidden Purple Palace in 1968 left nothing for restoration. A complete rebuilding of some of these structures is presently under way, introducing a theme park quality to the complex.  The complex is a ruin - and that’s central to its history. While some recreation makes sense, the ruins should also be embraced.

The Citadel fails to provide any narrative of substance to travellers. Only the most token descriptions are provided at key structures. Bao Dai’s dramatic abdication warrants only a couple of sentences. The Battle of Hue goes largely unmentioned. Visitors are left wondering.

The last king, Bao Dai, installed a tennis court which has been upgraded and now looks like a suburban tennis court anywhere in the world. It's presumably used by local officials. A sign at the front provides an insight into the questionable heritage values of the citadel's current custodians. It reads, "The restoration of King Bao Dai's tennis court aims at restoring one construction of historic value, serving tourist purposes, positively improving environment, and embellishing the landscape of the Forbidden Purple City".

For now at least, the Forbidden City’s rich tales of people, intrigue and battles, remain forbidden. Most travellers leave the place clueless. Proposals to “totally restore” the complex by 2020 will likely further diminish its historical significance.

A small allocation of funds to provide proper signage and descriptions, as well as insights into the people and events that took place here, would massively enhance the travel experience. For their 150,000VND, travellers receive a ticket from a dependably surly attendant and that's it.

Allow two hours for a comfortable stroll through the citadel grounds and start early or late to avoid the heat and crowds.

While the main sights - the Flag Tower, the Ngo Mon Gate, the Thai Hoa Palace, the Forbidden Purple City and the Ancestral Altars are easily covered more quickly, straying from the main route to the outer reaches and walking amidst the ruins, will give you a better sense of the scale of the place and the devastation that was wrought here.

A cycle or walk around the perimeter is also a nice way to get a sense of the scale of the place.


Travel Tips -
The citadel is downtown and can easily be reached by bicycle, cycle, motorcycle taxi (xe om) or on foot.
Approach on foot from the outer wall. This will give you a better sense of the scale of the place and give you some time to think about it all before you hit the crowds at the main entrance.

The citadel is large, mainly uncovered and can be crowded and very hot. Early mornings and late afternoon will be the most pleasant, least crowded and most picturesque.
If you’re in a hurry, a walk around the exterior of the citadel is worthwhile. You don’t necessarily need to go in.

Mark Bowyer
Mark Bowyer is the founder and publisher of Rusty Compass.
Support Rusty Compass
Rusty Compass is an independent travel guide. We’re focused on providing you with quality, unbiased, travel information. That means we don't receive payments in exchange for listings and mostly pay our own way. We’d like tourism to be a positive economic, environmental and cultural force and we believe travellers deserve disclosure from publishers. Spread the word about Rusty Compass, and if you're in Saigon, pop in to The Old Compass Cafe and say hi. It’s our home right downtown on Pasteur St. You can also check out our unique tours of Ho Chi Minh City at www.oldcompasstravel.com Make a financial contribution using the link below. Even small amounts make a difference. Thanks and travel well!

  • 11 of 23

There are no comments yet.